Vaccine to Prevent Throat Cancer

Spread through oral sex, it is well established that human papilloma virus (HPV) types 16 and 18 cause the vast majority of throat cancer especially in men... even more than smoking and drinking alcohol. What was not known, but suspected, was whether in BOTH men and women the HPV vaccine Cervarix (made by GSK) or Gardasil (made by Merck) would help prevent throat cancer as effectively as cervical cancer for which it is FDA approved for.

At least for the vaccine Cervarix, a randomized, control, double-blinded, prospective study has shown that it highly protects individuals from HPV 16 and 18 infection in the mouth/throat. The vaccine efficacy was calculated to be 93.3%. The big assumption being that reduced oral HPV 16/18 would lead to a decreased risk of throat cancer.

It is for these reasons that BOTH boys and girls are encouraged to get the HPV vaccine. We are talking about protecting our sons and daughters from getting throat and cervical CANCER later in life.

To be clear, more study is needed to really PROVE that such vaccines prevent throat cancer. For full disclosure, the weaknesses of this current study are as follows:

• It was performed only in women (the study would need to be replicated in males)
• The study lasted only 4 years... the question is whether life-long protection is present or will booster shots be needed?
• Does Gardasil also work for oral HPV 16/18?
• Does reduced HPV 16/18 presence in spit actually translate to decreased risk of throat cancer
• It is suspected that vaginal secretions carry a higher HPV viral load than the penis leading to a higher risk of throat cancer in men performing oral sex on infected women. As such, the other questions that need to be answered is whether such vaccines will:
     • Prevent a vaccinated woman from giving HPV to the man as well as
     • Prevent an infected woman to actually infect a vaccinated man?
     • Or, does BOTH partners need to be vaccinated to prevent HPV throat cancer?

It is truly an exciting time when vaccines can be given to prevent not only infections like mumps or shingles, but also cancer!

As a reminder, the HPV vaccines ONLY work when given to children before they become sexually active. It is too late to give the HPV vaccine for sexually active adults (ie, it won't work).

Source:
HPV Vaccine Found to Help With Cancers of Throat. NYT 7/18/13

Reference:
Reduced Prevalence of Oral Human Papillomavirus (HPV) 4 Years after Bivalent HPV Vaccination in a Randomized Clinical Trial in Costa Rica. PLOS One